Skip to main content
Boston Coin Buyers
Menu

Sell your coins with confidence in Boston

Have gold coins, silver dollars, rare coins, or an inherited collection? Talk with Boston Coin Buyers about your items and the next steps for an evaluation.

By appointment, Monday through Saturday, 10am to 6pm. Rather write? Request a call back.

Peace and Morgan silver dollars resting on a navy cloth
Peace and Morgan silver dollars. The Mint struck Morgans from 1878 to 1904 and again in 1921, and Peace dollars from 1921 to 1935.

Spot price per troy ounce

Gold $3,738.09

Silver $45.45

Bullion coins trade close to these numbers. Collector coins can sell well above them.

Selling your coins

  1. Call and tell us what you have

    Call (617) 209-6050 and describe the coins in your own words. A rough count and a few dates are plenty to start.

  2. Discuss your coins and evaluation options

    We talk through what you have, which pieces may carry collector value, and the best way to look at them. Then we set a time.

  3. Review the offer and decide whether to sell

    You see the offer before anything changes hands. Sell or keep your coins. Nothing is final until you say yes.

A straightforward approach to coin buying

Two coins with the same date can be worth very different amounts. Four things account for most of the difference, and we will explain how each one applies to the coins you have.

Silver and gold coins in a velvet tray, one under a magnifying glass
Rarity
How many were struck, and how many survived. Mint marks matter here. An 1893 Morgan dollar with the S mint mark of San Francisco is worth far more than one from Philadelphia the same year.
Condition
Wear, scratches, luster and any past cleaning. Collectors grade coins on a scale from 1 to 70, and a few points up that scale can change the price a great deal.
Precious-metal content
U.S. dimes, quarters and half dollars dated 1964 or earlier are 90 percent silver, and every gold coin is worth at least its gold. Spot prices set that floor.
Collector demand
Some series always have buyers, such as Morgan dollars and early U.S. gold. Others rise and fall with the market. Demand decides how far above metal value a coin can sell.

Coin appraisals and evaluations

An evaluation goes faster, and tells you more, when the coins arrive the way you found them. A few habits protect what they are worth.

We look at each coin for its date, mint mark, condition and metal content, and weigh gold and silver. Then you get an offer for the coins and decide what to do.

How our coin appraisals work

Before you bring coins in

  • Do not clean or polish collectible coins. Cleaning leaves fine scratches that collectors notice right away, and it lowers the price.
  • Keep collections organized when you can. Leave coins in their albums, folders, rolls and tubes, even if the order looks random.
  • Save the original packaging and paperwork. Mint boxes, certificates, grading holders and old receipts all help.
  • Call before bringing in a large collection. That way we can set aside enough time to go through it properly.

Coin buyers for Boston and Greater Boston

We work with sellers in Boston and the cities and towns around it, from Cambridge, Somerville and Brookline to Quincy, Newton and Waltham. Appointments are set by phone, Monday through Saturday.

Boston also has a coin history of its own, and pieces of it still turn up in Massachusetts homes.

  1. 1652 to 1682

    Massachusetts silver

    John Hull's mint in Boston struck the Willow, Oak and Pine Tree shillings, the first coins made in the English colonies. Most found today are replicas, and genuine ones are scarce.

    Pine Tree shilling values
  2. 1920 and 1921

    Pilgrim half dollar

    Governor William Bradford on the front, the Mayflower on the back. 90 percent silver with collector value.

    Pilgrim half dollar values
  3. 1925

    Lexington-Concord half

    The Minuteman statue and the Old Belfry. Sharp, unworn examples bring the most.

    Lexington-Concord half values

Frequently asked questions

Something else on your mind? Call (617) 209-6050 and ask.

Where can I sell coins in Boston?

You can sell them to Boston Coin Buyers. Call 617-209-6050 to describe what you have and set a private appointment, Monday through Saturday between 10am and 6pm.

How do I know what my coins are worth?

Start with the date, the mint mark and the metal. U.S. dimes, quarters and half dollars dated 1964 or earlier are 90 percent silver, and gold coins are always worth at least their gold. Rarity and condition decide the rest, and those are hard to judge at home. Call us and we can tell you which coins deserve a closer look.

Do you buy inherited coin collections?

Yes, from a single coin to a full estate. Leave everything as you found it and gather any paperwork, receipts or Mint packaging. If you are an executor, we can talk through the collection with you before you decide anything.

Should I clean my coins before selling?

No. Cleaning strips the original surface, and collectors pay less for cleaned coins. Bring them exactly as they are.

Do you buy gold and silver coins?

Yes. We buy U.S. gold coins, modern bullion coins such as American Eagles, Morgan and Peace dollars, pre-1965 silver dimes, quarters and half dollars, and gold and silver bars.

How do coin evaluations work?

We look at each coin for its date, mint mark, condition and metal content, and weigh any gold or silver. Then we make an offer, and you decide whether to sell.

Do I need ID to sell?

Yes. Anyone selling needs a government-issued photo ID.

Have coins to sell? Start with a conversation.

Tell us what you have. We can answer your questions on the phone and set up a time to see the coins.

(617) 209-6050

Call (617) 209-6050

By appointment, Monday through Saturday, 10am to 6pm.

Prefer to write?

Leave your name and number and we will call you back.

Call (617) 209-6050