Skip to main content
Free coin and gold appraisals by appointment across Greater Boston (617) 209-6050
Boston Coin BuyersCoins · Gold · Silver
Menu

Pine Tree shilling value: real or replica?

Updated November 2026

Short answer: Most Pine Tree shillings found in homes today are replicas sold as souvenirs. A genuine one is a thin, hand-struck silver coin from Boston and sells to collectors for a large sum. The first step is to find out which one you have.

Coins on a velvet tray under a loupe at a Boston appraisal

Boston's first mint

In 1652 the Massachusetts Bay Colony opened a mint in Boston, run by the silversmith John Hull with Robert Sanderson. England had not given permission, and the colony needed small change for trade.

The mint struck shillings, sixpence and threepence in silver. Over time it used three tree designs: the Willow Tree, then the Oak Tree, then the Pine Tree. Almost every coin carries the date 1652, no matter when it was made. The mint closed in the early 1680s.

Why so many replicas exist

The Pine Tree shilling became a symbol of colonial Massachusetts. Copies were sold at historic sites, given away as advertising and made into jewelry for well over a century. Many are old enough to look worn and dark.

A replica is still a nice keepsake. It just is not worth what a real one brings.

Signs of a real coin

These checks help, but none of them proves a coin is real on its own.

  • Real shillings are thin silver and weigh about 72 grains, close to 4.7 grams
  • They were struck by hand, so many are slightly off-center or uneven
  • The lettering reads MASATHVSETS IN around the tree and NEW ENGLAND AN DOM on the other side
  • Cast copies often show small pits, soft lettering or a seam on the edge
  • Copies made of brass, pewter or plated metal are the wrong color and weight

What a real one is worth

Genuine Massachusetts silver sells to specialist collectors. Price depends on the tree type, the variety, the condition and whether the coin was bent or clipped. Even worn genuine pieces bring strong prices.

We do not quote prices without seeing the coin, because the variety and condition decide so much.

Getting yours checked in Boston

Bring the coin in, with any family story or paperwork that came with it. We check it for free and tell you plainly whether it is genuine or a copy.

More questions

Why does every Pine Tree shilling say 1652?
The colony kept the 1652 date on nearly all its coins, likely to avoid trouble with the Crown over minting without permission.
Are Oak Tree shillings worth more than Pine Tree?
It depends on the variety and condition. Willow Tree pieces are the scarcest of the three types.

Thinking of selling? Read about colonial and early american coins, or send the form below.

Ask for a free offer

We call back the same day and book a private time.