Skip to main content
Free coin and gold appraisals by appointment across Greater Boston (617) 209-6050
Boston Coin BuyersCoins · Gold · Silver
Menu

Sell old coins in Boston

Indian Head cents, Buffalo nickels, Mercury dimes, Walking Liberty halves and the rest. We sort out the scarce dates and price every coin.

Chest of mixed old coins from a Greater Boston estate

Old coins from Boston homes

Old coins in Boston usually come from one of two places: a jar of pocket change saved by someone who lived through the Depression, or an album started by a kid in the 1950s with coins pulled from a paper route. We see both every week, from Dorchester to West Roxbury.

Those albums often stop where the coins got hard to find. A Whitman folder of Lincoln cents might have every slot filled except the 1909-S VDB and the 1914-D. The coins that are there still matter, and a few of them can surprise you.

Bring the whole lot as it is. Do not pull coins out of folders or roll them. We sort them during the appointment and show you which ones carry a premium.

How we sort an old coin collection

We start by separating silver from everything else, because silver carries value no matter the date. Then we go series by series: Lincoln cents, Buffalo and Jefferson nickels, Mercury and Roosevelt dimes, and so on up to halves and dollars. Inside each series we look for the dates and mint marks collectors pay extra for.

Condition comes next. A coin with sharp detail on the high points and no signs of cleaning sells for more than the same date worn smooth. We grade each candidate under magnification and tell you what we see, so the written offer makes sense when you read it later.

Common Boston finds and what they bring

Most of what turns up in Greater Boston homes falls into a handful of groups. Knowing them helps you set expectations before the appointment.

  • Wheat cents by the jar: sold in bulk, with scarce dates pulled out
  • Buffalo nickels: a little over face when worn, more with full dates
  • Mercury dimes and silver Roosevelts: silver value plus any date premium
  • Walking Liberty halves: silver value, more in sharp condition
  • Bicentennial coins: face value unless they are the 40 percent silver collector sets
  • Massachusetts state quarters from 2000: face value in circulated condition

Where people go wrong

The biggest mistake is selling the coins to the first buyer who quotes a single number for the whole lot. That number almost always assumes everything is common. A line-by-line offer protects you from that, because you can see exactly which coins got a premium and which did not.

The second mistake is cleaning. Old copper and silver tone over time, and many people scrub coins to make them look better before selling. It has the opposite effect on value. Bring them dull, dark and dirty. That is how collectors want them.

A Greater Boston coin appointment, start to finish

You arrive with whatever you have, in whatever it is stored in. We start by asking how the coins came to you, since a collection built by a hobbyist is priced differently from a jar of pocket change saved by a grandparent. Then we lay everything out and work through it group by group, talking as we go.

Most of the time is spent on the coins that might be worth more than face or metal. We look at each under magnification, check the date and mint mark, and grade it. Common coins get counted quickly. At the end, you get a written offer with each group and each better coin on its own line. You can accept all of it, part of it or none of it. If you take the offer, you are paid the same day. If you do not, you leave with your coins and the list.

Selling coins you collected yourself

Not every seller inherited their coins. Plenty of Boston collectors built their own sets over decades and are now ready to let them go. If that is you, you probably know more about your coins than most sellers, and you will want a buyer who respects that. Tell us which pieces you think are the best and we will look at them first.

Collectors often have records of what they paid. Bring them if you like. They help us understand the collection, though the offer is based on what the coins sell for today, not what they cost. We will explain where our numbers come from, and if you disagree on a particular coin, we are happy to talk it through.

Coins we buy

  • Indian Head and Lincoln wheat cents
  • Liberty and Buffalo nickels
  • Barber and Mercury dimes
  • Barber and Standing Liberty quarters
  • Walking Liberty and Franklin halves
  • Two-cent and three-cent pieces
  • Proof sets and mint sets
  • Rolls and bank bags

How we price old coins

We price each coin at the higher of its metal value or its collector value. Collector value depends on the date, the mint mark and the condition, and a small difference in wear can change the price a lot.

Pre-1965 dimes, quarters and halves are 90 percent silver and always carry metal value. Copper and nickel coins need a scarce date or nice condition to beat face value.

Further reading: What old coins are worth money?

Ask for a free offer

We call back the same day and book a private time.

Or call (617) 209-6050

Also buying

Common questions

Which wheat pennies are worth money?
The 1909-S VDB, 1914-D and 1931-S are the best known. Most wheat cents are common and sell in bulk, but we check every date and mint mark.
Are Buffalo nickels worth anything?
Most are worth a little over face, more if the date is still clear. The 1937-D three-legged variety and the 1913-S Type 2 carry large premiums.
Do you buy partial albums?
Yes. Leave the coins in the album and bring it as is.
Do you buy Indian Head pennies?
Yes. Most Indian Head cents are worth more than face, and some dates are worth a lot. Leave them uncleaned.
Should I take coins out of an old Whitman folder?
No. Leave them in the folder. Prying coins out can scratch them, and the folder helps us see the set.