Free coin appraisals in Boston
Find out what your coins are worth with no obligation. We grade every coin with you and give you the results in writing.
What to expect
Many Boston sellers come in only to learn what they have. That is fine. We go through each coin, tell you what we see and write it down. If you decide not to sell, you keep the coins and the list.
A few coins take about fifteen minutes. A full collection takes an hour or more, so we book the time to match.
Bring the coins as they are, in their original holders. Do not clean anything beforehand.
What we look for under magnification
Every coin gets the same check. We look at the date and mint mark first, then at the high points of the design, where wear shows earliest. We look at the surfaces for signs of cleaning, polishing or tooling, and at the rims for nicks and bumps.
For gold and silver, we also confirm weight and purity. Fakes and altered coins exist, and checking every piece protects both of us.
Why a written appraisal matters
A spoken number is easy to forget and hard to compare. A written list stays with you. You can show it to family, compare it with another buyer or simply keep it for reference.
Our written list describes each item, notes its condition and shows the price. If you decide not to sell, it is still yours to keep.
Appraisals for more than coins
Bring gold jewelry, sterling silver, bullion and old paper money to the same appointment. We price all of it at once, so you do not need separate visits for each kind of item.
Signs a coin may be worth more
You do not need to know anything to book an appraisal, but these are the signs that make us slow down and take a closer look.
- A small letter mint mark like S, D, O or CC
- A date before 1900
- Sharp detail with no flat spots on the high points
- Original luster that shimmers when tilted
- A coin sealed in a plastic grading holder
- Odd features like doubling, off-center strikes or missing details
After the appraisal
Once the appraisal is done, you have three choices. Sell everything on the written offer and be paid the same day. Sell part and keep the rest. Or keep it all and take the written list with you.
There is no deadline and no pressure. Some sellers decide on the spot. Others take a week or two, talk it over with family, and call back. The written offer reflects metal prices on the day, so if you wait, gold and silver lines may change with the market. Collector values move more slowly.
What we check
- Date and mint mark
- Wear and grade
- Signs of cleaning or damage
- Authenticity
- Metal content and weight
- Collector demand right now
What the appraisal is and is not
Our appraisal tells you what we will pay for each item today and why. It is a free purchase appraisal.
It is not a certified appraisal for court, probate, insurance or tax filings.
Further reading: What old coins are worth money?
Common questions
- How much does it cost?
- Nothing. The appraisal is free with no obligation.
- Can you value coins from photos?
- We can give a rough idea for some coins, but condition decides most of the price, so we need to see collector coins in person.
- Do I have to sell at the appointment?
- No. Take the written offer home and think it over.
- Can I bring coins from more than one family member?
- Yes. We can list each person's items separately on the written offer.
- Do you charge if I decide not to sell?
- No. The appraisal is free either way.