Short answer: Both coins are 90 percent silver and sell above their silver value because collectors want them. Worn coins bring a modest premium. Sharp, original coins with no wear bring much more.
The Pilgrim half dollar
The Pilgrim Tercentenary half dollar was struck in 1920 and 1921 to mark 300 years since the Mayflower reached Plymouth in 1620. Cyrus Dallin designed it, with Governor William Bradford on the front and the Mayflower under sail on the back.
Coins dated 1921 have the date added in the field on the front. They were made in smaller numbers than the 1920 coins and usually sell for more.
The Lexington-Concord half dollar
The 1925 Lexington-Concord Sesquicentennial half dollar marked 150 years since the battles of April 1775. The front shows the Minuteman statue in Concord by Daniel Chester French. The back shows the Old Belfry in Lexington, whose bell called the militia out.
Many were sold in small boxes, and some families still keep them that way.
What sets the price
Condition decides most of the price. On the Pilgrim half, check Bradford's cheekbone and hat. On the Lexington-Concord half, check the Minuteman's knee and hat. Those high points wear first.
- Worn coins sell a little above silver value
- Uncirculated coins with original luster bring much more
- Cleaned or polished coins sell for less
- Original boxes add a little for the Lexington-Concord half
Other commemoratives to look for
Families who saved these coins often saved others from the same era. Look for halves marking other states and events from the 1920s and 1930s. All are 90 percent silver and most carry collector value.
Selling in Greater Boston
Bring your commemoratives in whatever holder they are in. We grade each one in front of you and put the offer in writing.
More questions
- Is a Pilgrim half dollar silver?
- Yes. It is 90 percent silver.
- How do I know if my coin is uncirculated?
- Tilt it under a light. Original luster rolls across the surface like a cartwheel. Flat gray high points mean wear.
Thinking of selling? Read about old u.s. coins, or send the form below.
Ask for a free offer